PEO review · October 20, 2026

Extraordinary Insurance

Where you stand with Justworks today

A snapshot built from the reports you sent, and the topics we want to cover together.

Prepared for Elise Zambrano

Your Justworks admin fee

$109per person / month

PEO Plus plan, live since May 1, 2026

People billed in October

11

October admin fees

$1,199

Team11you plus 10 employees
States6CO, TX, GA, FL, ID, IN
Payroll~$520Ka year at today's pace
On medical2 of 11employee-only coverage

01 · Your team

A remote team spread across six states

From your Justworks census dated October 20, 2026. Please correct anything that looks off.

Where your people work

11 people on payroll, each state set up separately for taxes

CO 3
TX 3
GA 2
FL 1
ID 1
IN 1
5people hired since August
5people left since May

Who's on benefits

From your November coverage on the October 5 invoice

Medical 2 of 11
Dental 4 of 11
Vision 4 of 11

Why this matters: PEOs look closely at how many people are on the medical plan. People covered on a spouse's plan usually don't count against you, so knowing who turned coverage down and why helps us quote.

02 · Your bill

Your October 5 Justworks invoice

Fees and insurance only. Wages and payroll taxes are billed separately with each payroll.

LineShareAmount
Admin fees
11 people for October, plus 2 September hires
$1,417.00
Medical (November)
2 people at $713.49 each
$1,426.98
Dental (November)
4 people
$259.25
Vision (November)
4 people
$33.82
HSA fee
$5 a month per person using an HSA
$5.00
Total$3,141.05

Medical price per person

$663 → $713

Your original quote vs. the November invoice, about 7.6% higher. Confirm with your Nov 1 renewal

Colorado unemployment tax

About 5.16%

The rate Justworks charged on your October 16 payroll.

Workers' comp

About 0.2%

Of wages, built into each payroll. Our estimate

03 · Unemployment tax

Your state unemployment tax rates

What Justworks charged on your October 16 payroll, next to the standard 2026 rate for a new employer in each state. Sorted by yearly difference.

Justworks charged2026 new-employer rate
Yearly difference
Colorado3 people
5.16%
3.05%
$1,935
Texas3 people
4.32%
2.70%
$438
Indiana1 person · estimated
~5.5%
2.50%
$285
Idaho1 person
1.28%
1.00%
$157
Georgia2 people
3.42%
2.70%
$137
Florida1 person
2.70%
2.70%
$0
0%2%4%6%

At Justworks' rates

$7,982

A year for your current 11 people

At new-employer rates

$5,030

A year for the same people

Possible difference

$1,000 to $2,950

A year, depending on Colorado See note

About Colorado: it's about two-thirds of the difference. If 5.16% is your own Colorado rate, based on your history, it stays with you at any PEO and the difference is closer to $1,000 a year. Your yearly Colorado rate notice will tell us. How it's figured: each state taxes pay only up to a yearly limit, so this uses your current people and pay rates for a full year. Every new hire starts a new limit, so turnover adds to both columns. Indiana is estimated from year-to-date payroll.

See the math by state
StateWages taxedAt Justworks' rateAt new-employer rateDifference
Colorado (3)$91,800$4,735$2,800$1,935
Texas (3)$27,000$1,167$729$438
Indiana (1)$9,500$522$238$285
Idaho (1)$56,160$719$562$157
Georgia (2)$19,000$650$513$137
Florida (1)$7,000$189$189$0
Total (11)$210,460$7,982$5,030$2,952

04 · Your contract

What your Justworks agreement says

From the Customer Service Agreement you signed on April 15, 2026.

30 days' notice, no annual contract

Flexible

You can leave anytime with 30 days' written notice. Less notice means paying 30 days of admin fees anyway.

SECTION 9.1

Fees can change with 30 days' notice

Watch for 2027

Justworks can change fees with 30 days' notice, and workers' comp at any time. Justworks has announced $124 per person for PEO Plus starting January 1, 2027.

SECTION 4.2

New coverage must start the day you leave

Plan ahead

Health and workers' comp have to be in place on day one. If not, Justworks charges $400 a month for each person on COBRA.

SECTION 4.25

Invoiced taxes and insurance can be more than Justworks' cost

Good to know

The agreement says amounts billed as taxes, premiums or contributions may be higher than what Justworks actually pays, and Justworks keeps the difference. That's why we compare total cost, not just the admin fee.

SECTION 5.3

05 · Today's topics

What we'd like to cover today

1

Your experience with Justworks

Who you call, how fast you hear back, and what you miss from Insperity.

2

Your team and hiring plans

Headcount over the next year, new states, and whether everyone works 30+ hours.

3

Who's on benefits and why

Who turned coverage down and why, and your own coverage.

4

Your November 1 renewal

What changed in price and plans this fall.

5

Your benefit goals

How much you want to contribute, plan choices, and adding a 401(k).

6

2027 pricing and timing

The January price change and the cleanest date to make a move.

06 · Next steps

A clean path to January 1

1

This week

Fill in a few details

We'll follow up by email

2

About a week later

Side-by-side quotes

Total cost, not just fees

3

By Thanksgiving

You decide

Stay or switch

4

By December 1

30-day notice

Only if you switch

5

January 1, 2027

Go live

New coverage ready day one

Why January 1 works well

  • Payroll tax limits reset that day anyway, so nothing gets paid twice.
  • Justworks' new pricing starts that day.
  • Only two months into your medical plan year, which started November 1.